Righthand vs Magic: AI vs Human Virtual Assistants
Compare Righthand AI assistant with Magic's human virtual assistants. See cost, availability, and capability differences.
Feature Comparison
| Feature | Righthand | Magic |
|---|---|---|
| 24/7 Availability | 24/7 option available | |
| Instant Response | ||
| Calendar Management | ||
| Email Management | ||
| Research Tasks | Basic | |
| Human Judgment | Limited | |
| Predictable Pricing | Hourly | |
| No Minimum Hours | ||
| Voice Interaction | ||
| Scales Without Hiring |
Why Choose Righthand
Predictable Cost
Righthand has flat monthly pricing. Magic charges $15-35/hour, which can add up quickly and unpredictably.
Instant Response
Righthand responds immediately, every time. Human assistants have response delays and availability gaps.
No Hour Tracking
Use Righthand as much as you need without watching the clock. Magic requires tracking hours carefully.
Consistent Quality
Righthand delivers consistent performance. Human VA quality varies by individual and workload.
Pricing Comparison
Righthand
Starting at $99/month, unlimited interactions
Magic
$15-35/hour, ~$600-2,400/month typical usage
The Verdict
Choose Magic if you need human judgment for complex research, creative tasks, or unpredictable work. Choose Righthand if you want reliable, instant assistance for scheduling, email, and standard tasks at a predictable cost.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Righthand cheaper than Magic?
Usually, yes. Magic costs $15-35/hour, easily reaching $1,000+/month. Righthand provides unlimited assistance starting at $99/month.
Can Righthand do what Magic VAs do?
For scheduling, email, and routine tasks, yes. Magic VAs are better for complex research, creative work, and tasks requiring human judgment.
Which is faster?
Righthand responds instantly. Magic VAs respond within minutes to hours depending on availability and task complexity.